Close Reading and Text Annotations are great strategies to help students dig deeper into texts.
Teachers shared their best advice on these topics:
- What close reading means to them
- How to select texts for close reading
- What types of assignments are good to practise close reading
- Paper and digital annotation suggestions
Read the curated Twitter chat below to learn more about close reading and text annotations.
Q1: What does “close reading” mean in your classroom?
- Close reading means reading & rereading text to analyze literal & figurative meaning. Students do this to form deeper connections
- Close reading in my classroom means to read the text with a specific focus, questions after reading go beyond explicit info
- Close reading means looking beyond the gist of what is read, finding deeper meanings, and multiple reads
- Close reading to me has always been repeated reading and talking with fellow readers.
- It means reading a text more than once. Each time with a specific purpose
- Close Reading means my students analyze the text, by focusing on key details in order to gain a deeper understanding
- Close reading is slowing down reading to carefully notice details. Love this introductory activity: http://whoswhoandnew.blogspot.com/2014/12/close-reading-with-oreos.html
- Dissecting a text and analyzing author’s craft
- Several draft readings with a different purpose each time with chunking in one of the readings
- Close reading includes making and forming connections with a text, hopefully connecting it with events in the students lives
- Agreed! Questions go beyond literal comprehension
- Close reading=inquiry into how a text achieves its effects & what is revealed about writer’s purposes
- Close reading is reading with purpose. I.e. Observing text features, specific elements, deeper meaning. Beyond the literal
- In the big picture- reading/marking text with a defined purpose. Changes depending on what we are studying
- Close reading: several readings of the text. Each reading is for a different purpose. Analyzing text to determine author’s purpose
- My students are currently doing a Close Reading of @Newsela nonfiction articles about the upcoming election!
Q2: What types of texts do you ask students to do a close reading of? For what purpose?
- Being a 1:1 classroom. We also annotate text digitally!
- We close read ALL text: fiction, nonfiction, poetry. We do this to look at author’s intentions and reader’s experience
- To me, close reading means the students are very involved in the reading and think critically about the reading
- I think it’s funny that close reading seems like a new goal. Hasn’t reading closely always been a goal in ELA?
- Shorter, complex texts so poems or excerpts from a larger work are perfect
- I try to keep texts short for close reading. Poems, stories, speeches and excerpts of longer texts
- We regularly close read our class novels and our Article of the Week readings
- Important to remember everything isn’t meant to be closely read. We close read shorter texts, excerpts, and most nonfiction
- My only close reading teaching experience was with Shakespeare. Unfamiliar language lends itself to a careful, second look!
- I have my students read all sorts of text: informational, fiction, poetry, speeches
- We focus more on close reading class novels and shorter works to help build their endurance
- Persuasive text – identify & evaluate arguments. Poetry – meaning through specific word choice
- I’ve found that shorter texts/excerpts work best for my students. Sometimes I’ll pull a paragraph or two from a larger text
- Article of the Week is a great strategy for jumping into close reading
- ALL types of text! This week we’ve read folktale for theme/point of view, a speech for big ideas about life goals
Q3: How do you teach text annotation to your students?
- I teach annotating the text, by having students use the app Xodo. They are able to make annotations on the digital prompt
- That’s awesome! I love how you share specifically what you’re doing! Never heard of Xodo app – Gotta check it out!
- Absolutely! But #commoncore made it a priority & gave it a label
- I follow the standard @AVID4College annotation strategies from both my Avid and English students
- I model and do a “think aloud” as we read a text to teach annotation
- Modeling! Then baby steps to “find” certain things on their own. I make it like a scavenger hunt at first
- Modeling on a song students would be familiar with. Using different colored markers can help keep beginner students organized
- Ooohhh….speeches would be great for this! Which ones specifically do you do?
- Think Alouds and help students set purpose. Generally, students share in partners before discussion with class
- I model annotation for my students, taking them through my thought process as I’m reading
- Color marking; marginalia sorted left hand= elements of argument (nonfiction); right hand=style/lit devices. Plus doodling
- Do you ever do texts that might not be traditionally classified as “texts” like videos?
- This year I’m starting with @KyleneBeers & @BobProbst‘s Notice and Note for #nonfiction #text
- For our first trimester I’ve been following this format: https://twitter.com/itsmrsleonardo/status/788535120944693248/photo/1
Q4: Do you have a standardized method of annotation or so you allow students to develop their own?
- I use standard marks & allow students to create their own. I encourage students to write in the margins.
- We start with a question, followed by a search for the answer in the text. We highlight potential answers as we read
- Think aloud and lots of examples with different text. And, different ways to interact with text. Options=tools. Find what works for students.
- No one set way of annotating, will vary from assignment to assignment. Having all students use the same markings on the same assignment makes for an easy visual check of understanding
- I always start with standard (6th grade) but then advance. Students eventually are “weaned”
- Love this idea for poetry that I got the other night https://twitter.com/susanclaireb/status/787824917156884480
- I require comments, questions. No summaries. @writeguyjeff‘s Question: What do you notice? After 1st read I call these “Noticings.”
- I’ve started with some standard marks. This is my 1st year to really do it seriously, so it’s still a learning process for me
Q5: For what types of assignments do you require text annotation? How do you grade these assignments?
- I don’t grade annotation. It is the students thought process in understanding text. Instead, I grade a related writing assignment
- Usually require text annotation before writing about that text, also do annotation as part of revision in the writing process
- The highlighting method is the first (and only) one I’ve learned, but I would love to teach my students more!
- Love this! @writeguyjeff “Noticings” are great! Makes me think of curiosity and how we lose it as we get older
- We are reading a Novel and annotating it according to the 4 embedded assessment options at the end of the unit
- I do not grade annotation, but rather what the students do with it.
- Do you ever have students share their annotations with each other to compare?
- I grade writing using annotations as text evidence. Sometimes if students use post-it’s with textbook, they attach to handout
- We annotate short passages mostly. I’m looking to see that students are documenting their thought process through their annotations
- What if they are not “going deep?” How do you encourage that?
- My team uses annotation for lessons relating to short answer response; we don’t read any novels. I wish we did
Grab Great Teaching Tips!
Subscribe to our email list to get engaging teaching and lesson ideas, as well as special subscriber only bonus resources sent directly to your email address.